To my dear friends who read this blog: I know many of you have been affected or troubled in some way by the recent City Harvest Church debacle. I've decided to write this article about it because I am quite disturbed about it too. I am disturbed by the fact that so many non-Christians are able to see through the shenanigans of these people, yet many Christians (especially CHC-goers) continue to stubbornly support the church.
I am not trying to pass judgement on any individuals involved in CHC because God is the supreme judge! However God's Word warns us of false shepherds in the last days coming in the guise of lambs. In Paul's first letter to the Corinthian church, he tells them to "expel the immoral brother!"
Why? Because Paul understood the simple philosophy that "a little yeast works through the whole batch of dough" (1 Corinthians 5)
What I'm trying to say here is- as followers of Christ, we should not easily accept anyone or any philosophy that comes in the guise of Truth and Light. Test everything against God's Word and in prayer (1 John 4:1).
If there is one bad seed that plants itself in God's holy universal church, do not call it a good seed! It is to be uprooted before weeds overgrow and choke up the whole place.
In other words, we are to set ourselves apart from the things that we know do not glorify God or are false, lest we be lumped together with the yeast.
_______________________________________________
Those of you who are in Singapore would undoubtedly have caught wind of the breaking news that shook the island a few days ago. City Harvest Church, with the largest congregation in Singapore of about 15,000 members was recently embroiled in yet another count of embezzlement charges. This time, the famous pastor Kong Hee and four others in CHC's administration were charged in court with much evidence surfacing from an investigation of the church funds which started back in May 2010.
The amount found to have been misappropriated by these people rounds at a whopping $50.6 million. Sadly, such an outrageous case of corruption in CHC comes with no surprise to many Singaporeans. Why? Here's a bit of context:
CHC is pastored by Kong Hee, a wealthy businessman and his wife, Sun Ho, a Chinese pop singer. These people are charismatic (both in their manners and in their beliefs) and pride themselves on reaching out to the youth via the hype and flash of pop concerts.
This church has earned a reputation for concert-type worship sessions, drawing fans of Sun Ho and other worshippers of the Prosperity Gospel.
Unfortunately, the pastors' wealth have caused many outsiders to question the validity of their lifestyle. I mean, how many millionaire pastors do you know? How would you feel sitting in the congregation, listening to a rich man who has two cars, maids and a butler read these following Bible verses?
"Sell your possessions and give to the poor. Provide purses for yourselves that will not wear out, a treasure in heaven that will not be exhausted, where no thief comes near and no moth destroys." (Luke 12:33)
"Now listen, you rich people, weep and wail because of the misery that is coming upon you." (James 5:1)
"People who want to get rich fall into temptation and a trap and into many foolish and harmful desires that plunge men into ruin and destruction." (1 Timothy 6:9)
_______________________________________________
Now I'm not saying that all rich people who claim to be Christians are doomed to an eternity in hell. But there are two things that I always keep in mind when thinking about the whole CHC fiasco.
First of all, having a lot of wealth is not a good thing for one's relationship with God, but it does not make it impossible for one to enter heaven.
Matthew 19:24 says "it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God".
Note that this verse doesn't actually mention the word IMPOSSIBLE. Indeed, it is possible for a camel to go through the eye of a needle. In fact, I've often thought about the possible ways for a camel to enter the eye of a needle as a kid and this is what I came up with:
1) Make the eye of the needle really big- bigger than a camel.
2) Ground up the camel into powder or liquid and have it poured through the eye of the needle. (It doesn't say whether the camel has to be alive or not right?)
Now the problem with option 1 is that if we assume the needle refers to heaven in Matthew 19:24, then there's no way option 1 would be feasible. In Matthew 7:14, it says "small is the gate and narrow the road that leads to life, and only a few find it".
I don't think the needle's eye will be enlarged anytime soon.
That then leaves me with option 2. A rather gruesome approach of entering the needle's eye I must say. But it clearly illustrates my point (which I'm coming to). It is not impossible for a rich man to enter heaven, but it is an exceedingly difficult, painful and arduous process full of spiritual barriers. It is certainly a path that no man can embark on on his own strength and prowess. Because it is such a difficult road, we can only assume that very very few people ever make it.
In my own life, I have experienced financial and material ups and downs. It is during the times when I was financially and materially down that I found it the easiest to trust and obey God. However when life started looking up and I no longer had to scrimp and worry, I found my mind often wandering from Christ.
See, when I was "richer", I had more things to entertain myself with and I could very easily find fast and convenient satisfaction outlets whenever I was feeling down and out. Very quickly, I realised that being "rich" was a huge stumbling block in my walk with Christ. Not insurmountable, but huge nonetheless (thank God for the millions I don't have!)
People always think that life gets easier when you've got lots of money.
Sure, some things get easier. But if you're talking about a relationship with Jesus Christ, there's no scarier trap than the trap of a comfortable life in the deep-set armchair of riches and fame.
Knowing this puts many doubts in my mind about the soundness of CHC's teachings. While much of what Kong Hee quotes from the Bible is true, some other things he says
in this video just makes me feel plain uncomfortable... It's like he's trying to
justify being rich. Why does being rich need justification in the first place?
Ok bear with me, I'm on to my second point about this CHC's fiasco.
_______________________________________________
Now that I've talked about how being rich can be a stumbling block, I'll proceed with how being a pastor or shepherd of God's flock puts one at a different position from others.
Firstly, James 3:1 tells us that "not many of you should presume to be teachers... because... we who teach will be judged more strictly".
Judged by who? By God? By men? I don't know. It doesn't say. Perhaps both. But one thing is for sure; the teachers of God's Word carry more weight of responsibility than any other believer. For all he's worth, Pastor Kong Hee and his wife Sun who claim to bear the burden of preaching the gospel to young fans of pop music, claim a heavy load indeed.
As servants of the Most High God, should their weightier spiritual position also mean greater fame and riches on this earth?
On the contrary, Philippians 2 paints a very different picture of the Highest of Highs and King of Kings. We are told in the letter to the Philippians that Jesus, the ultimate example of humility, actually "did not consider equality with God something to be used to his own advantage; rather, he made himself nothing by taking the very nature of a servant"
And since "no servant is greater than his master" (John 15:20), how can I reconcile the humility of Christ with the lavish lifestyle of these two pastors who claim a great responsibility in the kingdom of God?
_______________________________________________
Some Christians outside of CHC warn us not to throw the baby out with the bath water even now that Kong Hee and his colleagues have been charged with embezzlement. They say we should not discount the people who are truly saved by their encounters in this church. While I agree that there may have been some people that were saved in CHC, I have nothing to say about how hearts have been transformed by the power of the Holy Spirit there.
And because my answer to this is more experiential than based on hard fact, you don't have to take my word for it.
Of all the people whom I know that are staunch members at City Harvest Church, not a single one actually tries to model their lives after Christ or finds their glory in Him. To elaborate further, these CHC members seem rather to be modeling a life of stardom and wealth, often giving praise to Kong Hee or their cell group leaders instead of Jesus Christ. An arbitrary "praise God!" or "Amen!" might be mouthed, but ultimately it is Kong Hee who seems to receive the most praise and gratitude.
It is this aspect that I find most disturbing about CHC.
We are to worship God in truth and spirit (John 4:24); not by growing one's bank account, gaining more friends and popularity or by looking like you're going clubbing when you're going to church. Christian fellowship is ultimately for the glory of God, not the glory of oneself!
Anyway, when all this is said and done, the conclusion I have come to is simply to pray for the true believers in CHC and also for Kong Hee and his wife Sun Ho. Ultimately, we do not know what God's purpose in their lives really is, but there are some lines that I would draw between myself and City Harvest Church.
I do not endorse the entire shade of the Prosperity Gospel they preach, nor the lifestyle that the pastors and church goers lead.
If a friend of mine decides to seek Christ in City Harvest Church (or New Creation Church, for that matter), I would strongly discourage it because I have seen for myself what spiritual havoc their teachings can wreak in a person's life. A fig tree cannot bear olives. Similarly, a church filled with the Holy Spirit, based firmly on the foundation of Christ alone cannot bear anything but the fruit of the Holy Spirit.
Therefore, in these matters, let us be wise as serpents but simple as doves, always giving thanks to God for His amazing grace shown to us undeserving sinners.
After all, the Son of God did come to seek what was lost.
